Historical Record
As for the historical record of Guo En, there is no clear entry in the official histories presently verifiable. c:1 This means that in sources such as the Records of the Three Kingdoms, the figure Guo En is not mentioned, and his life, official posts, allegiance, and the role he played in the course of Three Kingdoms history are all impossible to verify. We therefore cannot draw any concrete image or historical contribution of Guo En from the historical materials. This reflects, to some degree, the limitations of the historical record: many figures who may have existed or played a role at the time failed, for various reasons, to be included in the official histories, and so were submerged in the long river of history. For researchers, figures lacking documentary record are often hard to investigate and analyze in depth, and their authenticity and historical standing are difficult to establish. Such is precisely the case with Guo En, who is in a state of "absence" in the official histories, leaving us unable to make any statement about him grounded in historical fact. c:1
In the Novel
In that great literary work Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Guo En is likewise a figure not clearly fashioned. c:2 According to the available information, Guo En appears in the novel in chapter sixty-nine, and is mentioned only in that single chapter, indicating that his role in the novel is extremely limited—he may even be a figure passed over in a single stroke, never possessing an independent storyline or notable words and deeds. The novel commonly creates or adapts figures as the plot requires, but Guo En's case does not seem to be of that kind; he received no rich brushwork from the author Luo Guanzhong. c:2 This handling leaves Guo En in a vague and indistinct state in Romance of the Three Kingdoms as well, and the reader can learn nothing of his character, motives, or specific deeds from the novel. Unlike many figures who are given vivid images in the novel, even departing from historical fact, Guo En lacks even basic literary shaping, so that his presence in the novel is virtually nil. Thus, whether from the standpoint of historical fact or of literary creation, Guo En is an extremely marginal figure. c:2
Key Relationships
Given that neither the historical nor the novelistic materials record Guo En in detail, we cannot establish any "key relationship" between Guo En and any other figure. c:1c:2 In history or literature, relationships between figures are often an important component in driving the plot and revealing character—for example, the relationship of lord and minister, of friends, of enemies, can all endow a figure with deeper meaning. For Guo En, however, owing to his "invisible" state in both the historical and the novelistic materials, we cannot connect him to any known historical figure or novelistic character. He is neither recorded as a subordinate of some lord, nor described as the comrade or rival of some hero. This lack of key relationships further throws into relief Guo En's marginal place in the historical and literary narrative. Any conjecture about Guo En's relationships with other figures would lack factual basis and be pure imagination. Thus, in discussing Guo En, we must acknowledge the blank in his web of relationships. c:1 c:2
Iconic Scenes
Likewise, since neither the historical nor the novelistic materials contain any concrete record of Guo En, we cannot depict any "iconic scene" for him. c:1c:2 An iconic scene usually refers to a distinctive moment in which a figure, through his words and deeds in a historical event or literary plot, displays his character, ability, or role in a particular event—for example, Guan Yu slaying Hua Xiong while the wine was still warm, or Zhang Fei shouting to break the bridge at Dangyang—all of which are highly recognizable iconic scenes. Guo En, however, is not mentioned in the historical sources, and in the novel appears only fleetingly, with no concrete episode developed. This means he took part in no important battle, uttered no words handed down to later ages, and accomplished no feat worth recording. Guo En therefore has no scene that could be called "iconic," his image always vague and blank upon the stage of history and literature. Any attempt to construct an iconic scene for him would be without textual support. c:1 c:2
Relationships
1 relationships
Other1
Chapters1 回 ▸
- 史ch.29